Logitech Swytch vs.
Extend vs. Active USB Cable: A Detailed Comparison
In
today's world of hybrid work and flexible meeting spaces, having the right
tools to connect and collaborate seamlessly is essential. Logitech offers a
range of solutions designed to simplify video conferencing and content sharing
in various environments. This article delves into a comprehensive comparison of
three popular Logitech products: Swytch, Extend, and Active USB Cable,
examining their features, capabilities, and ideal use cases to help you make an
informed decision.
Logitech Swytch: The Versatile BYOM Solution
for PC-Based Rooms
Logitech
Swytch is a BYOM (bring your own meeting) solution designed to bridge the gap
between personal laptops and dedicated room systems. It allows users to connect
their Windows 10 - 64 bit or later laptop, MacBook (macOS 10.15 or later), or
Chromebook (Chrome OS 75 or later) to the room's AV equipment with a single
USB-A or USB-C connection 1. This eliminates the need for multiple cables and
adapters, streamlining the meeting experience.
Key Features and Capabilities
●
Single-Cable Connectivity: Swytch utilizes DisplayLink Plug-and-Display technology,
enabling both USB device and HDMI display connectivity through a single cable 2.
●
BYOM Flexibility:
Swytch allows users to leverage the room's display, camera, microphones, and
speakers with any video conferencing application, webinar service, or streaming
platform 2.
●
Power Delivery:
Swytch provides up to 60 watts of power to laptops that charge via USB-C,
ensuring uninterrupted meetings 3.
●
High-Quality Video and Audio: Swytch supports full-motion video and audio at up to 4K
resolution, delivering a high-quality meeting experience 2.
●
Remote Management:
IT administrators can monitor and manage Swytch remotely using Logitech Sync,
along with other Logitech meeting room devices 2.
Intended Use Cases
Swytch is ideal for:
●
Meeting rooms with dedicated computers: Swytch allows users to connect their laptops to existing
room systems like Microsoft Teams Rooms and Zoom Rooms while still supporting
third-party services 2.
●
BYOM rooms with a conference camera and display: Swytch provides a simple way for users to connect their
laptops and utilize the room's AV equipment 1.
●
Huddle spaces and small meeting rooms: Swytch's compact design and ease of use make it suitable
for smaller collaboration spaces.
Known Issues and
Limitations
While Swytch offers a
compelling solution for BYOM connectivity, it's essential to be aware of
potential issues:
●
DisplayLink Driver Dependency: Swytch relies on DisplayLink drivers, which can
sometimes cause compatibility issues or require updates 4. In some
cases, users have reported that the display feed intermittently cuts out,
requiring them to reinstall or update the drivers 4.
●
USB Tier Limitation:
Swytch consumes two USB layers, which can be a limitation when connecting
multiple peripherals due to the USB industry standard of seven layers 5. This can be
problematic if you need to connect several devices, such as a camera,
microphone, and speakerphone, simultaneously.
●
Occasional Connectivity Issues: Some users have reported intermittent display issues or
difficulty connecting certain laptops 4. For example, some users have experienced issues with
the Rally Camera not automatically reconnecting to the room system PC after
using Swytch 7.
●
Lack of Ethernet Passthrough: Swytch does not pass through the wired Ethernet
connection from the room system to the connected laptop, potentially requiring
users to rely on Wi-Fi 8. This can be a drawback in environments with poor Wi-Fi
signal strength.
Logitech Extend: Simplifying BYOD in Larger
Rooms with Android-Based Systems
Logitech
Extend is designed to enhance the BYOD experience in larger meeting rooms
equipped with Android-based Logitech conference cameras, such as the Rally Bar
family 9. It allows users to bypass the pre-configured video
conferencing platform on the room system and use their preferred platform on
their laptop or mobile device. The Logitech Extend is priced at $799 USD, with
availability beginning in November 11.
Key Features and Capabilities
●
BYOD Passthrough:
Extend enables users to temporarily override the room system's default video
conferencing platform and use their own device and preferred application 9.
●
Extended Reach:
Extend supports extended cable reach up to 100 meters using Cat6a cables,
making it suitable for larger rooms 12.
●
Power Delivery:
Extend offers optional power delivery up to 100W for connected devices,
ensuring they remain charged during meetings 13.
●
No Additional Drivers:
Extend utilizes USB-C with DisplayPort Alt Mode, eliminating the need for
additional drivers or software 11.
●
Simple Management:
Extend can be managed remotely through Zoom Device Management and Microsoft
Teams Admin Center as part of CollabOS device updates 14.
Compatibility
Logitech
Extend is compatible with Windows, Mac, Android, Google Meet, Microsoft Teams,
and Zoom. However, compatibility may vary by platform and service provider 14.
Environmental Impact
Logitech
is committed to creating a more sustainable world and is actively working to
minimize its environmental footprint 14. The Logitech Extend is made with a minimum of 40%
post-consumer recycled plastic, contributing to this effort 11.
Intended Use Cases
Extend is particularly
well-suited for:
●
Larger meeting rooms with Android-based room systems: Extend's extended cable reach and BYOD passthrough
capabilities make it ideal for larger spaces 12.
●
Meeting rooms requiring flexibility: Extend allows users to choose their preferred video
conferencing platform without being limited to the room system's default 9.
●
BYOD-focused environments: Extend simplifies connecting personal laptops and mobile
devices to the room's AV equipment 10.
Known Issues and
Limitations
While Extend offers valuable
benefits, consider these potential limitations:
●
Compatibility:
Extend is primarily designed for Android-based Logitech room systems and may
not be compatible with all setups 14.
●
Limited to USB-C:
Extend uses USB-C connectivity, which may require adapters for laptops with
only USB-A ports.
●
No Switching Functionality: Unlike Swytch, Extend does not offer switching
capabilities between a room PC and a BYOD laptop 15. This means
that you cannot easily switch between using the room's dedicated system and a
user's laptop.
Logitech Active USB Cable: A Cost-Effective
Solution for MeetUp 2
Logitech
Active USB Cable is a specialized cable designed to enable a single-cable BYOD
connection for the Logitech MeetUp 2 video conferencing system 16. It supports
DisplayPort Alt Mode, allowing users to connect their laptop to MeetUp 2 with
just one USB-C cable, eliminating the need for separate HDMI connections. This
simplifies the connection process and reduces clutter 17. The Active
USB Cable enables a single-cable connection for use with the Logitech MeetUp 2
video conferencing system 16.
Key Features and Capabilities
●
Single-Cable BYOD:
Active USB Cable simplifies connecting a laptop to MeetUp 2 for BYOD meetings 16.
●
Fast Data Transfer:
With USB 3.1 Gen 2 support, the cable ensures smooth video and audio quality
during meetings 18.
●
Optimal Length:
The 5-meter (16.4 ft) cable provides flexibility in small meeting rooms 16.
●
Magnetic Dock: The
cable includes a magnetic dock for neat cable management 18.
●
Reliable Strength:
Unlike ordinary USB cables, the Active USB Cable is built to withstand pulling
and crushing forces, with a tensile strength of 200 newtons and a crush load of
1000 kg 19. This makes it suitable for commercial deployments where
cables might be subject to stress.
Intended Use Cases
Active USB Cable is best
suited for:
●
Huddle spaces and small meeting rooms: The cable's length and single-cable connectivity are
ideal for compact meeting spaces 12.
●
BYOD meetings with MeetUp 2: The cable simplifies connecting laptops to MeetUp 2
without needing additional adapters 17.
●
Cost-conscious setups:
Active USB Cable offers a more affordable solution compared to Swytch and
Extend 13.
Known Issues and Limitations
●
Limited Compatibility:
The Active USB Cable is specifically designed for the Logitech MeetUp 2 and is
not compatible with other Logitech devices.
●
No Power Delivery:
The cable does not provide power to the connected laptop.
●
Distance Limitations:
Active USB cables have inherent distance limitations due to signal degradation.
While the Active USB Cable is 5 meters long, exceeding this length might lead
to performance issues 20.
Comparison Matrix
|
Feature
|
Logitech Extend
|
Logitech Swytch
|
Active USB Cable
|
|
Ideal Room Size
|
Any room
|
Any room
|
Huddle and Small
|
|
Room Solutions
|
Microsoft Teams Rooms on
Android,...
|
Rally Bar family, MeetUp,
Rally Bar 13
|
MeetUp 2
|
|
User Cable
|
5 ft (1.5 m) USB (Type C) 13
|
5 ft (1.5 m) USB (Type A
and Type C) 13
|
16.4 ft (5 m) USB (Type C)
13
|
|
Box-to-box Cable Length
|
Up to 328 ft (100 m) with
Cat6a (user supplied) 13
|
16.4 ft (5 m) USB 3.0
cable (included) 13
|
N/A
|
|
Drivers
|
No additional drivers
required 13
|
DisplayLink driver
required 13
|
None 13
|
|
Power Delivery
|
Up to 100W (user-supplied)
13
|
Up to 60W 13
|
N/A (no power source) 13
|
Conclusion
Logitech
Swytch, Extend, and Active USB Cable each cater to different needs and
scenarios within the realm of video conferencing and BYOD connectivity.
Choosing the right solution depends on your specific requirements, such as room
size, existing equipment, budget, and desired functionality.
Logitech Swytch is a versatile solution best suited for PC-based rooms
where users need to seamlessly switch between using a dedicated room system and
their own laptops. It offers high-quality video and audio, power delivery for
laptops, and remote management capabilities. However, it relies on DisplayLink
drivers, which can sometimes cause compatibility issues.
Logitech Extend simplifies BYOD in larger rooms with Android-based
systems. Its key strengths are extended cable reach, BYOD passthrough, and
optional power delivery. However, it lacks switching functionality and is
primarily designed for Android-based setups.
Logitech Active USB Cable provides a cost-effective and straightforward way to
connect laptops to MeetUp 2 in huddle spaces. It offers a single-cable solution
with fast data transfer and a magnetic dock for cable management. However, it
is specifically designed for MeetUp 2 and does not offer power delivery.
To
further aid in your decision-making, here's a table summarizing the pros and
cons of each product:
|
Product
|
Pros
|
Cons
|
|
Logitech Swytch
|
Versatile BYOM solution
for PC-based rooms Single-cable connectivity High-quality video and audio Power delivery
for laptops Remote management
|
Relies on DisplayLink
drivers USB tier limitations Occasional
connectivity issues No Ethernet passthrough
|
|
Logitech Extend
|
Simplifies BYOD in larger
rooms Extended cable reach Optional power delivery No additional drivers Environmentally
friendly design
|
Limited compatibility No switching functionality
|
|
Logitech Active USB Cable
|
Cost-effective solution
for MeetUp 2 Single-cable BYOD Fast
data transfer Reliable strength
|
Limited compatibility No
power delivery Distance limitations
|
By
carefully considering these factors, you can choose the Logitech solution that
best enhances your video conferencing experience and meets the needs of your
meeting spaces.
Penulis
